Montreal Smoked Meat
Victorian / Belle Époque
Montreal Smoked Meat
Also known as Smoked meat sandwich, Smoked meat on rye, Boeuf mariné
4 places claim to have invented this one. The case file is below.
ContestedAnatomy of the Montreal Smoked Meat

Origin story
Montreal, Quebec, Canada · 45.52°N, 73.58°W
Montreal smoked meat is a cured, spiced, smoked and steamed beef brisket, hand-sliced and piled on rye with yellow mustard, and it is the work of Jewish immigrants from Romania and Eastern Europe.
Montreal smoked meat is a cured, spiced, smoked and steamed beef brisket, hand-sliced and piled on rye with yellow mustard, and it is the work of Jewish immigrants from Romania and Eastern Europe. Its fame is tied to Schwartz's, opened in 1928 on Boulevard Saint-Laurent by Reuben Schwartz, a Romanian-born immigrant. But smoked meat was in the city before Schwartz's; the Wikipedia account calls the true origin uncertain and probably unresolvable, and the surrounding stories name several earlier figures.
1884
The story that Aaron Sanft, a Romanian immigrant, opened Montreal's first kosher butcher shop and used a Romanian method of preparing meat; told as a story, not a verified record [3]
The Dispute
We don't adjudicate. Here is the evidence for each claim, neutrally, with its source.
Montreal smoked meat is a cured, spiced, smoked and steamed beef brisket, hand-sliced and piled on rye with yellow mustard, and it is the work of Jewish immigrants from Romania and Eastern Europe. Its fame is tied to Schwartz's, opened in 1928 on Boulevard Saint-Laurent by Reuben Schwartz, a Romanian-born immigrant. But smoked meat was in the city before Schwartz's; the Wikipedia account calls the true origin uncertain and probably unresolvable, and the surrounding stories name several earlier figures.
Ben's De Luxe Delicatessen, Montreal
Benjamin Kravitz of Ben's De Luxe Delicatessen is credited by some as the person who introduced it, in 1910, and his family says he used a brisket-curing method he remembered from Lithuanian farmers.
Evidence: [1]
Unnamed claim
Historian Eiran Harris says Herman Rees Roth may have made the first smoked meat sandwich in 1908, and a separate account has Itzak Rudman bringing it over in 1902.
Evidence: [1]
Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Aaron Sanft, who arrived from Iasi, Romania, in 1884 and opened the city's first kosher butcher shop, likely made a Romanian-style smoked meat close to pastrami.
Evidence: [1]
Our reconstruction
Notes on this reconstruction
We give the Schwartz's style as the standard served sandwich: brisket piled high on light rye with yellow mustard. That is a choice about construction, not a verdict on who invented it. The sources agree on the process (salt and spice cure for roughly a week to ten days, hot smoke, then steam), but each deli's spice blend is guarded, so ours is a plausible reconstruction with a heavy hand on cracked pepper. A home smoker is not the same as a deli's brick smokehouse; the oven-and-steam shortcut below gets the texture, not the smoke. Brisket varies in fat, and customers at a deli ask for lean, medium or fat; we suggest medium.
- Yield
- 4 sandwiches
Method
Mix the salt, sugar, pepper, coriander, mustard seed and garlic into a rough paste, and rub it all over the brisket.
Seal the meat in a bag or covered dish and keep it in the fridge for 7 to 10 days, turning it daily and pouring off the liquid it releases.
Rinse off the surface cure, pat the brisket dry and press on a fresh coat of cracked pepper and coriander.
Smoke it at a low heat, around 120 degrees Celsius, for several hours until it has a dark crust. If you have no smoker, roast it in a low oven on a rack with a dish of water beneath.
Wrap the brisket tightly and steam it for about three hours, until a knife slides in easily.
Carve thick slices against the grain while the meat is hot, or better, hand-cut them so the slices fall apart a little.
Spread mustard on the rye, heap the meat generously between two slices, and serve with pickles.
Sources
- Montreal-style smoked meat: Wikipedia (retrieved 2026-10-30) Origins uncertain; Kravitz/Ben's 1910; Roth 1908; Rudman 1902; Sanft 1884; preparation; served on light rye with yellow mustard
- Schwartz's: Wikipedia (retrieved 2026-10-30) Opened 31 December 1928 by Reuben Schwartz as the Montreal Hebrew Delicatessen; 10-day cure; smoked meat on rye with yellow mustard; Ben's rivalry
- Schwartz's: Montreal's most famous deli: Tastet (retrieved 2026-10-30) Schwartz's opened 1928 by Reuben Schwartz; says smoked meat predates it, with the story of Aaron Sanft in 1884, presented as a story and not verified