Muffuletta

Victorian / Belle Époque

Plate No. 047

Muffuletta

Also known as Muffaletta

On the record since 1906. Uncontested: French Quarter, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA takes the credit.

Medium confidence

Anatomy of the Muffuletta

Muffuletta, exploded anatomy plate

Origin story

French Quarter, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA · 29.96°N, 90.06°W

Salvatore Lupo, a Sicilian immigrant, opened Central Grocery at 923 Decatur Street in 1906, in the section of the French Market known as 'Little Palermo' for its concentration of Sicilian grocers and pushcart vendors.

Salvatore Lupo, a Sicilian immigrant, opened Central Grocery at 923 Decatur Street in 1906, in the section of the French Market known as 'Little Palermo' for its concentration of Sicilian grocers and pushcart vendors. According to his daughter Marie Lupo Tusa, farmers and market workers would come in at lunchtime and buy cold cuts, cheese and olive salad separately, along with a round, sesame-crusted Sicilian loaf also called muffuletta, then try to eat all of it standing up or balanced on a knee. Lupo started assembling it into one sandwich for convenience, and it became the shop's signature. No contemporary 1906 written record of the moment survives (the story comes from family oral history recorded decades later), so the year is well attested by the family and the location, but not by a period document.

1906

Salvatore Lupo opens Central Grocery at 923 Decatur Street in the French Quarter: the shop credited with combining the separately sold cold cuts, cheese and olive salad into one sandwich [1]

Our reconstruction

Medium confidence

Medium confidence: the dish is documented, the original formulation is not

Notes on this reconstruction

Dish and construction are both well documented today at Central Grocery itself, but the exact 1906 proportions are not: this is a working sandwich shop's recipe passed down inside one family, not a written original. The olive salad is the part worth getting right; it needs to be made ahead and allowed to sit so its oil works into the bread rather than sitting inertly on top of the meat.

Yield
1 loaf, cut into 4–6 wedges
Based on
[1] [2]

Method

  1. Make the olive salad first and give it time: combine the olives, giardiniera, celery, garlic, oil, oregano and vinegar and leave it at room temperature for at least an hour, longer if you can: it should taste briny and loose with oil, not dry.

  2. Split the loaf horizontally and pull out a little of the soft crumb from each half to make room for the filling without the sandwich becoming unmanageably tall.

  3. Spoon a generous, oil-heavy layer of olive salad onto both cut faces: this is what seasons the whole sandwich, so don't be shy with it.

  4. Layer the salami, ham, mortadella and provolone in overlapping folds rather than flat stacks, so every bite gets a bit of each.

  5. Close the loaf, wrap it tightly in paper or foil, and weight it under something heavy for at least 30 minutes. This isn't optional: an unpressed muffuletta falls apart on the first bite.

  6. Cut into wedges to serve. It holds well and is traditionally made ahead rather than eaten fresh off the counter.

Sources

  1. Muffuletta Sandwich: 64 Parishes (retrieved 2026-09-24) 1906, Salvatore Lupo, Central Grocery, Little Palermo
  2. Muffuletta: Wikipedia (retrieved 2026-09-24) Construction; Marie Lupo Tusa family account
  3. Central Grocery and Deli: Home of the Original Muffuletta (retrieved 2026-09-24)