Reuben
Jazz Age
Reuben
3 places claim to have invented this one. The case file is below.
ContestedAnatomy of the Reuben

Origin story
Omaha, Nebraska, USA · 41.26°N, 95.93°W
Two Reubens, two cities, and the documentary evidence does not cleanly favour either.
Two Reubens, two cities, and the documentary evidence does not cleanly favour either. The Omaha account has Reuben Kulakofsky, a Lithuanian-born grocer, asking for corned beef and sauerkraut at a weekly poker game at the Blackstone Hotel some time between 1920 and 1935, and a 1934 Blackstone menu does list a Reuben sandwich, which is the only hard artefact in the whole dispute. Complicating even that, one account credits the hotel's chef Bernard Schimmel with the actual construction, adding the dressing and grilling it.
1934
A Blackstone Hotel menu listing the Reuben sandwich: the earliest physical documentation in either claim [1]
The Dispute
We don't adjudicate. Here is the evidence for each claim, neutrally, with its source.
Two Reubens, two cities, and the documentary evidence does not cleanly favour either. The Omaha account has Reuben Kulakofsky, a Lithuanian-born grocer, asking for corned beef and sauerkraut at a weekly poker game at the Blackstone Hotel some time between 1920 and 1935, and a 1934 Blackstone menu does list a Reuben sandwich, which is the only hard artefact in the whole dispute. Complicating even that, one account credits the hotel's chef Bernard Schimmel with the actual construction, adding the dressing and grilling it.
New York City, USA
Arnold Reuben, the German-Jewish proprietor of Reuben's Restaurant on East 58th Street, is said to have made a 'Reuben Special' around 1914, but of ham, turkey, Swiss and coleslaw on rye, which is not the sandwich anyone means today. The earlier date favours New York; the ingredients do not.
Evidence: [1]
Omaha, Nebraska, USA
Bernard Schimmel, the Blackstone's chef, rather than Kulakofsky: the poker player specified the fillings, the kitchen made it a sandwich.
Evidence: [2]
Our reconstruction
Notes on this reconstruction
We reconstruct the Omaha version, because it is the one the 1934 menu attaches to and the one whose ingredients match what people now call a Reuben. Griddled in butter rather than dry-toasted, per the Schimmel account. Russian dressing rather than Thousand Island: they are close cousins and sources split on which; Russian is sharper and we think better here, which is a preference and we are saying so rather than dressing it as fact.
- Yield
- 1 sandwich
Method
Squeeze the sauerkraut hard in a clean cloth until it stops giving up liquid. Wet kraut is the difference between a Reuben and a wet tragedy.
Butter one face of each slice of bread. That face goes to the pan.
Build on the dry faces: dressing, cheese, corned beef, kraut, then the second slice of cheese so it seals the kraut away from the bread.
Griddle over medium-low, weighted with a second pan, until the underside is deep brown and the cheese has begun to run, about 4 minutes.
Turn carefully and repeat. Low and slow: the inside has to heat through before the outside burns.
Rest for a minute, then cut on the diagonal so the layers show.
Sources
- Reuben sandwich: Wikipedia (retrieved 2026-09-22) Kulakofsky c.1920–1935; 1934 Blackstone menu; Arnold Reuben c.1914 'Reuben Special'
- The Hotly Contested Origin Of The Reuben Sandwich: Tasting Table (retrieved 2026-09-22) Bernard Schimmel attribution; dressing and grilling
- Reuben sandwich: Britannica (retrieved 2026-09-22)