Gatsby

Fast-Food Seventies

Plate No. 031

Gatsby

On the record since 1976. Uncontested: Athlone, Cape Town, South Africa takes the credit.

High confidence

Anatomy of the Gatsby

Gatsby, exploded anatomy plate

Origin story

Athlone, Cape Town, South Africa · 33.97°S, 18.52°E

Made in 1976 by Rashaad Pandy at Super Fisheries in Athlone, on the Cape Flats.

Made in 1976 by Rashaad Pandy at Super Fisheries in Athlone, on the Cape Flats. Pandy had promised to feed the workers who had cleared a plot for him and was short of time, so he filled a whole Portuguese loaf with slap chips, polony and atchar and cut it into wedges. One of the workers called it 'a Gatsby smash', after the 1974 Robert Redford film then showing at a cinema nearby, and the name stuck. The circumstances are not incidental: Pandy was classified 'Indian' under apartheid, and the plot in question was in an area newly designated under the Group Areas Act. The Gatsby is a Cape Flats food because the Cape Flats was where the state put people.

1976

Super Fisheries, Athlone: Rashaad Pandy's improvised loaf for the workers who cleared his Lansdowne plot [1]

Our reconstruction

High confidence

High confidence: well documented, our reconstruction is close to the original

Notes on this reconstruction

We give the original 1976 build (chips, polony, atchar) rather than the masala steak or fish-and-calamari versions that now dominate, because the polony one is the documented first. Slap chips are the load-bearing ingredient and the name tells you how: 'slap' is Afrikaans for limp. They are fried soft on purpose, then doused in vinegar, and they soak into the bread rather than sitting on top of it. A crisp chip here is a mistake, not an upgrade. A Gatsby is a full loaf and is meant to be cut into four and shared.

Yield
1 loaf, cut into 4 portions
Based on
[1] [2]

Method

  1. Fry the chips once at a moderate heat until cooked through and pale: soft, not crisp. Do not double-fry them; limp is the specification.

  2. Drain, salt heavily, and splash generously with white vinegar while still hot so it steams into them.

  3. Fry the polony slices in a dry hot pan until the edges curl and brown.

  4. Split the loaf lengthways, keeping a hinge, and open it out flat.

  5. Spread atchar along the bottom face, then lay in lettuce and tomato.

  6. Pack the chips in along the whole length (far more than looks sensible), then the polony over them, and finish with chilli sauce.

  7. Close, press down firmly with the flat of your hand, and cut into four. Eat while the vinegar is still working into the bread.

Sources

  1. Gatsby (sandwich): Wikipedia (retrieved 2026-09-22) 1976, Rashaad Pandy, Super Fisheries, Athlone; Portuguese loaf, chips, polony, atchar; 'Gatsby smash'
  2. Notable Sandwiches #72: The Gatsby, The Sword and the Sandwich (retrieved 2026-09-22) Group Areas Act context; Pandy's racial classification; the 1974 Redford film and the naming
  3. Gatsby: Gastro Obscura (retrieved 2026-09-22)