Hot Dog

Victorian / Belle Époque

Plate No. 036

Hot Dog

Also known as Frankfurter in a bun, Coney Island red hot, Wiener, Frank

4 places claim to have invented this one. The case file is below.

Contested

Anatomy of the Hot Dog

Hot dog, exploded anatomy plate

Origin story

Coney Island, New York, USA · 40.58°N, 73.97°W

The sausage is European and the bun is the American part of the story.

The sausage is European and the bun is the American part of the story. The account most often repeated for the sausage-in-a-roll is that Charles Feltman, a German immigrant, began selling frankfurters on a bun from a pushcart at Coney Island in 1867, calling them Coney Island red hots, and later grew the stand into a vast seaside restaurant. That account is a popular tradition rather than a documented receipt: the term 'hot dog' itself does not appear in print until the 1880s and 1890s, and rival claimants in Europe and the American Midwest have their own stories.

1884

The earliest printed use of the words 'hot dog' that the Wikipedia article cites, for sausage meat in a newspaper; the sausage-in-a-roll sense appears in print from 1892 [1]

The Dispute

We don't adjudicate. Here is the evidence for each claim, neutrally, with its source.

The sausage is European and the bun is the American part of the story. The account most often repeated for the sausage-in-a-roll is that Charles Feltman, a German immigrant, began selling frankfurters on a bun from a pushcart at Coney Island in 1867, calling them Coney Island red hots, and later grew the stand into a vast seaside restaurant. That account is a popular tradition rather than a documented receipt: the term 'hot dog' itself does not appear in print until the 1880s and 1890s, and rival claimants in Europe and the American Midwest have their own stories.

Frankfurt am Main, Germany (with Vienna, Austria)

The sausage came first and the place name came with it. Frankfurt pork sausages (Frankfurter Würstchen) are recorded from the thirteenth century, while the 'wiener' takes its name from Vienna, where a pork and beef sausage was made. Butcher Johann Georg Lahner is said to have taken the frankfurter to Vienna. On this view the American hot dog is a descendant, not an invention.

Evidence: [1]

St Louis, Missouri, USA

A German immigrant sausage seller named Feuchtwanger is credited with putting sausages in buns in St Louis. One version says his wife suggested it around 1880 because customers kept walking off with the gloves he lent them to hold the hot sausages; another ties the rolls to the 1893 Chicago or 1904 St Louis fairs.

Evidence: [1]

Polo Grounds, New York, USA

Harry Stevens, a ballpark food concessionaire, reportedly served sausages in small French rolls at the Polo Grounds in 1901 after his supply of waxed paper ran out.

Evidence: [1]

Our reconstruction

Contested

Contested: rival origin claims with real evidence behind more than one

Notes on this reconstruction

We build the plain American stand version that the 3D model shows: a grilled frankfurter in a soft split-top white bun, with yellow mustard and bright green sweet pickle relish. Nothing here is a reconstruction of Feltman's 1867 red hot, whose sausage and bread are not documented, so we are describing the standard served dish rather than the first one. The split-top (New England style) bun is a choice: it has flat sides that take butter and a toaster-friendly crust, and it stays shut around a sausage better than a side-split roll. Ketchup is a regional argument we have left out.

Yield
4 hot dogs
Based on
[1] [2]

Method

  1. Warm a grill or heavy pan over a medium-high heat and rub it lightly with oil.

  2. Score each frankfurter shallowly along its length, then lay them on the heat and turn them every minute or so until they are blistered in places and hot through, about 6 minutes.

  3. Butter the flat sides of the buns and toast them in the same pan until pale gold, working quickly so the middle stays soft.

  4. Open the buns along the top, set a frankfurter in each, and run a line of mustard down the length of the sausage.

  5. Spoon the relish over the mustard so it sits in the groove, and serve straight away while the sausage is still hot and the bun is still warm.

Sources

  1. Hot dog: Wikipedia (retrieved 2026-10-30) Frankfurt and Vienna sausage origins; Feuchtwanger; Feltman 1867; Harry Stevens 1901; earliest print uses of 'hot dog'; common toppings
  2. Before Nathan's there was Feltman's: The history of the Coney Island hot dog: 6sqft (retrieved 2026-10-30) Feltman's pushcart 1867; Coney Island red hots; presents Feltman as inventor of the hot dog on a bun and does not discuss rival claims